I stumbled across this idea to create jars to keep track of what she gets done
http://lullabylubbock.blogspot.com/2011/07/ellas-good-girl-jars.html
I like the idea for when she's a bit older and ready for goal-setting. At this point, she probably won't like the idea of having to put something cute and fun to play with inside a jar where she can't just get it back out and play with it.
I needed something to bridge the gap, to give her immediate gratification AND something visual. My answer: Aislinn's Almost-Big-Girl Chore chart. They're not really chores, but stuff that I expect her to be able to do with little or no help from me. I'll put it right under Mommy's chart on the lower part of the fridge, so that she can reach it.
